As a Panthers fan, frustration has become all too familiar. It seems like every time this team gets close to controlling its destiny, the same issues resurface. Part of it is the youth of the roster, but another part lies in execution and coaching. Dave Canales has done remarkable work building a strong culture in Carolina, but talent and culture alone aren’t enough.
Panthers’ Mistakes Hand Saints Victory
Sunday’s 17–20 loss to the New Orleans Saints perfectly illustrated this struggle. With a win, the Panthers could have seized sole possession of first place in the NFC South after Tampa Bay’s loss earlier in the week. Instead, Carolina gave up a late comeback fueled by rookie quarterback Tyler Shough and rookie kicker Charlie Smyth, blowing yet another golden opportunity.
The Saints Are Who We Thought They Were
The Panthers entered Week 15 with momentum. Wins over Green Bay and the Rams, combined with a bye week, should have primed the team for success. Then, Tampa Bay’s loss created a clear path to first place, an opportunity on a silver platter. All they had to do was win.
What makes Sunday’s result even more troubling is that the Panthers had already faced the Saints earlier this season and lost. New Orleans, now 4-10 after the victory, this team has struggled for most of the year. Yet for any team, games against division opponents are always tough because of the familiarity. The Saints are exactly what we expected: a team that might not dominate most opponents but knows Carolina well, making these matchups harder to win.
Carolina couldn’t close. It’s a story fans have seen too many times. Despite mature messaging from the locker room and strong leadership all week, the team faltered when it mattered most. Carolina is still young, still learning how to handle success, and Sunday was another painful reminder.
Bryce Young Shines, but It Wasn’t Enough
Bryce Young was not the problem. He played one of his more complete games of the season, going 15-of-24 for 163 yards, a touchdown, and a 96.4 passer rating, adding 49 rushing yards on seven scrambles. Young extended plays, made high-level throws. Including a standout connection to Jalen Coker. That kept Carolina in the game until the final moments. Young needs to keep improving, but he was not the reason for the loss today. If asked, he will say he could have played better or that there were things he missed.
But this loss was not on him; it was on missed opportunities and mental errors elsewhere on the team.
Penalties and Mental Errors Undermined Carolina
Discipline was a major problem. The Panthers had 11 penalties for 103 yards—the most all season. Before this game, Carolina was ranked 5th in the league for fewest penalties, so this was a big step backward. You can’t win games by giving opponents extra chances like this.
-
Unnecessary Roughness: Late hits extended Saints drives and forced Carolina into difficult third-down situations.
-
Illegal Formations and Offsides: Early drives were repeatedly negated, including a potential field goal that was nullified due to an offside penalty.
-
Drive-Killing Mistakes: A key sequence saw Bryce Young take a hit near the sideline, followed by Ikem Ekwonu retaliating and drawing a penalty that erased a promising scoring drive. Later, Ekwonu allowed a crucial sack, further stalling the offense.
-
Special Teams Penalties: Kickoff and punt return infractions erased valuable field position and momentum.
Even with Bryce Young playing well, these mistakes kept giving New Orleans chances to win, and they took full advantage.
Failure to Close on Both Sides of the Ball
Up 17–7, Carolina had multiple chances to put the game away. The run game stalled, only having 78 yards rushing between the two backs. Multiple drives ended with punts or a turnover on downs, and the defense couldn’t get off the field on key third downs. Dropped interceptions and contested catches compounded the frustration. Good teams capitalize on opportunities; learning teams let them slip.
Credit Where It’s Due
The Saints deserve credit. Tyler Shough showed growth, and rookie kicker Charlie Smyth delivered a pressure-packed 47-yard field goal to win it. Veterans like Demario Davis and Cam Jordan stood tall, proving that they have pride. The Experience they bring can tip the scales in close games.
Final Lesson or Same Old Cycle?
The Panthers are still alive in the NFC South, but their path is narrow—they must beat Tampa Bay twice to win the division. The potential is there, but trust must be earned. Youth, mistakes, and inconsistency continue to haunt this team.
Maybe this loss will serve as the final lesson, forcing Carolina to clean up penalties, execute situational football, and finally close games under pressure. Or maybe it’s just another chapter in a frustrating cycle of progress and regression. Either way, the opportunity remains: sweep Tampa Bay, and Sunday’s loss becomes a footnote. Fail again, and it’s another sign the Panthers aren’t ready for the moment.
Keep pounding
Main Photo Credit: Scott Kinser-Imagn Images
The post Panthers’ Mistakes Hand Saints Victory appeared first on Last Word on NFL.